Showing posts with label pointofview. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pointofview. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 21, 2011

21/09 POINT OF VIEW / Genichiro Takahashi: 'Softness' is key to thought-provoking message



SPECIAL TO THE ASAHI SHIMBUN
2011/09/21
Printopen the story for print
Share Article このエントリをはてなブックマークに追加 Yahoo!ブックマークに登録 このエントリをdel.icio.usに登録 このエントリをlivedoorクリップに登録 このエントリをBuzzurlに登録
photoGenichiro Takahashi (Photo by Atsushi Takanami)
I had my eureka moment the other day when I saw the cover of the August issue of "Neppu" (Hot wind), a booklet published by Studio Ghibli, an animation film studio co-founded by director Hayao Miyazaki.
The cover showed Miyazaki doing a one-man street demonstration near his studio in the western Tokyo suburb of Higashi Koganei. He is wearing an apron, and a signboard hangs from his neck. The signboard says, "NO! Genpatsu (nuclear power generation)."
I just said a one-man demonstration, but actually he's not alone. Walking behind him are a woman and a man, the former carrying an umbrella and the latter accompanied by a dog on a leash and his right hand holding a signboard that says, "Stop."
Except for the signboards, the trio (plus the dog) could just as well be enjoying a leisurely stroll in the neighborhood.
The scene somehow reminded me of the popular "Mito Komon" TV samurai drama series, in which the protagonist, Komon-sama, is always accompanied by his two loyal sidekicks, Suke-san and Kaku-san.
Just ahead of the trio is a man on a bicycle coming their way. The expression on his face seems to say, "Huh? This goofball is the Hayao Miyazaki?! Well, I never."
The picture was so funny, and I loved it. And it made me think.
It was funny and yet profoundly thought-provoking because of its "softness." By "softness" here, I mean you can read just about anything into this picture and react to it in any number of ways. For instance, you might be simply impressed by Miyazaki's determination to oppose nuclear power generation. Or, you might sense the loneliness of someone who has chosen to crusade for a cause, and remind yourself that no crusade should be divorced from your day-to-day life. You might also realize, with a sigh, that there is something sadly comical about someone who wears his social conscience on his sleeve.
What made Miyazaki take to the streets? The reason must be that he had something he felt he had to tell people. But you've got to bear in mind that just saying what you think won't get you anywhere. It's vital that you give your audience "space" to thoroughly ponder your message. And that "space" is what makes the message "soft."
I was still feeling the impact of the "Neppu" cover picture when I picked up the September issue of Bungei Shunju magazine and read the policies of three candidates for president of the Democratic Party of Japan--Yoshihiko Noda, Sumio Mabuchi and Banri Kaieda who went misty-eyed over a disagreement he had with then-Prime Minister Naoto Kan.
I was totally disappointed with their writings. They bored me to tears. Each man had his own way of saying things, but what they said was all the same.
On the government's nuclear policy, for instance, they said it was going to be difficult to keep promoting nuclear energy after the Fukushima disaster, but various economic considerations rendered any hasty decommissioning of existing nuclear reactors impossible. As for tax hikes, they are necessary given the current fiscal plight, they argued, but this is still not the right time to increase taxes.
Simply put, all three candidates were being "pragmatic." But their "pragmatism" was obviously predicated on maintaining the status quo.
Haven't they learned anything from what our country has experienced over the last six months? Or perhaps they don't really have any message they want to communicate to the public. If they did, they would have at least tried to do a better job of it, wouldn't they?
By the way, I've always wondered if it's a requirement for prime ministerial hopefuls to contribute policy commentaries to Bungei Shunju. I don't know how this custom came to be, but I can sort of understand this must be the "pragmatic" thing to do.
And in the same issue that featured the three prime ministerial candidates' commentaries, the magazine also ran the article about the Akutagawa literature prize sponsored by the magazine. As a writer, I couldn't help rolling my eyes. It was like being told, "See, this is what being an 'Establishment' insider is all about."
A recent issue of Kanagawa Daigaku Hyoron, an academic magazine published by Kanagawa University, introduced three poems as part of its "Jasmine Revolution" special. The poems and their bibliographical notes gave me a lot to think about. Each poem should be called "a poem from Tahrir Square" for providing a first-hand account of what transpired at this iconic revolutionary landmark. What surprised me was all these poems were first introduced on television, and then went viral on YouTube and blogs.
Not only in the Arab world but also around the globe, poetry was losing its centuries-old social function, but the revolution revived the value of verse. According to Kaoru Yamamoto, who translated the poems and compiled their bibliographical notes, the poems captured the hearts of people "in Egypt where rampant corruption and hypocrisy in all segments of society had eroded the credibility of words, and people were starving for words they could believe." If that is the case in Egypt, I cannot but worry about our country as well.
Ryoichi Wago, a poet living in Fukushima Prefecture, recently tweeted a poem about the March 11 disaster and created quite a sensation. Novelist Hiromi Kawakami rewrote her earlier work to depict the horror of the Fukushima disaster and published it in Gunzo magazine. Cartoonists Moto Hagio and Kotobuki Shiriagari pulled no punches in their starkly graphic portrayal of the Great East Japan Earthquake and the Fukushima nuclear disaster.
What is common to their works is that none of the creators even bothered to seek perfection in their writings and drawings. They all had a message they felt compelled to communicate, and for that they were forced to go against the "established" rules in their respective fields--or at least that was how I saw it. And what these four people had to face couldn't be unique to "creative" fields of work alone.
Lastly, I would like to touch on a column by Kiichi Fujiwara about the Japanese insensitivity to the Chinese train disaster in July. "The Japanese were visibly satisfied, saying that this sort of accident couldn't happen in Japan," Fujiwara wrote. "But few Japanese mourned the Chinese dead--victims of a railway service that takes human lives lightly. Few Japanese felt the pain of this tragedy as their own." Underlying this insensitivity is the deep-seated Japanese prejudice and hostility against China (and other countries). I would like to address this ugly aspect of our society at a later date.
* * *
Genichiro Takahashi is a professor of contemporary literature at Meiji Gakuin University. He plans to publish "Koisuru Genpatsu" (Nuclear power station in love), his most recent novel that deals with nuclear power generation. Takahashi collaborated with Tatsuru Uchida in selecting stories that were published recently as "Uso Mitai na Honto no Hanashi" (Unbelievable true stories).

Friday, July 1, 2011

01/07 POINT OF VIEW/ Yasuhiro Hayashi: Combination of smart grid, storage batteries can lower dependence on nuclear power



SPECIAL TO THE ASAHI SHIMBUN
2011/07/01

photoYasuhiro Hayashi (Photo by Kazuhiro Yokozeki)
Some people probably think it is possible to reduce Japan's dependence on nuclear power simply by aggressively promoting the use of renewable energy sources like solar and wind power.
But these natural, alternative energy sources have a serious drawback. The amounts of electricity generated with these sources are greatly affected by natural conditions, such as hours of sunlight and wind velocity. In other words, these are very unstable sources of electricity.
Quality control is vital for a dependable power supply. Electricity utilities in eastern Japan, for instance, need to keep the outlet voltage of their electricity supplies between 95 volts and 107 volts and their frequency between 49.8 hertz and 50.2 hertz, while balancing their power generation with changing consumption.
If large amounts of electricity generated with unstable renewable energy sources are fed into the grid, they will cause wild fluctuations in power output, making it difficult to maintain the quality of electricity supplies.
The ongoing research on smart grid technology could lead to a realistic solution to this problem. The goal is to develop technology to link the electrical grid to an information network in a way that allows efficient control of power supply and consumption.
Storing electricity for household use has long been a tough technological challenge. But the widespread use of electric vehicles would offer a convenient way to solve the challenge because electricity could be stored in the batteries of the vehicles.
Used batteries for electric vehicles can be diverted to use at homes. It is also possible to store electricity in the form of thermal energy by using a heat pump water heater for household use.
If a smart meter--an electrical meter that can track electricity consumption in real time and send that information back to the utility--is installed in households, it will be possible for each household to store electricity and thermal energy while PV power output is high and use the stored energy for home consumption when output is low.
The core function of the smart grid is to allow flexible storage and use of electricity in response to the changing balance between power output and consumption.
The technology can be a remedy for the problem of output fluctuations of power generation using natural energy sources as well as curb overall electricity consumption during peak demand hours.
Until now, electric utilities have been forced to spend huge sums of money to build facilities like nuclear power plants to have reserve capacity for peak demand. The smart grid will also help them cut their capital investment.
If electricity rates are set to vary according to changes in power output, households will be benefited by, for example, storing electricity during the hours when the rates are low. In short, the smart grid system combined with electricity storage devices would provide for smart energy saving without pain.
But smart grid technology will not be a cure-all. How much power from renewable energy sources can be fed into the grid and how sharply power consumption can be slashed during peak hours depend on the entire network's capacity of storing electricity.
Fortunately, Japan has cutting-edge technology for both storage batteries and heat pump water heaters. I believe that Japan will be able to achieve technological innovations.
In order to promote these innovations, the government should increase the use of renewable energy sources and promote smart grid technology to cover the supply from the nine nuclear reactors that will be built by 2020 under the government's basic energy development plan.
That would be a realistic first step toward lowering Japan's dependence on atomic energy.
(This article was compiled from an interview by Hiroyuki Ota.)
* * *
Yasuhiro Hayashi is director of the Research Institute of Advanced Network Technology, Waseda University. Born in 1967, Hayashi is an expert in electrical energy systems. He heads an advisory panel on the smart meter system for the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry. His published works include "Sumaato Guriddo Gaku" (Research of smart grid).

Wednesday, June 29, 2011

29/06 POINT OF VIEW/ Noriko Hama: Grand coalition makes a mockery of two-party politics



Special to The Asahi Shimbun
2011/06/29

photoNoriko Hama (Photo by Atsushi Takanami)
In an almost criminal waste of previous taxpayer time, a legion of lawmakers have been engaged
in nakedly partisan political maneuvering over the so-called grand coalition between the ruling Democratic Party of Japan and the main opposition Liberal Democratic Party.
It is completely unclear to the voters what those politicians aim to do after realizing the grand coalition or what kind of policy goals really require a grand coalition.
Such a grand coalition between the ruling and opposition parties should be regarded as a last resort under a democratic political system. The fact that lawmakers so readily embrace such a proposal clearly shows how dysfunctional this nation's politics is.
If the ruling and opposition parties cannot develop constructive and cooperative working relationships without striking a grand coalition deal, that underscores the poverty of Japanese politics.
If the two camps cannot make cooperative responses to this serious crisis unless they establish such a framework, a two-party system is simply a pipe dream.
The opposition side is totally obsessed with its political goal of returning to power, while the ruling camp is fixated on holding on power. There is clearly no room for the dynamics of a democratic political system to work properly.
Such a situation inevitably breeds political opportunism. Now, the Japanese public is feeling that both camps are using the rhetoric of effective responses to the disaster for their political gains.
Before the regime change two years ago, some DPJ lawmakers were saying they wanted to see a two-party system take root in Japan.
Immediately after the power shift, there were expectations among the public for productive competition for a public mandate between the ruling and main opposition parties and constructive involvement in the battle by other parties.
But both sides have started talking about a grand coalition with a disturbing lack of discretion and prudence. Politics should not be a plaything of these irresponsible politicians.
Germany was ruled by a grand coalition of major parties between 2005 and 2009. But it is hard to say that the alliance gave strength to the country's politics.
The current situation in Japan apparently reflects the fact that Japanese politicians don't understand that politics and government exist, and are allowed to exist, only to serve the public. In other words, these politicians lack professionalism.
There are ways for an opposition party to play a constructive role in policy making. After decades in power, the LDP must have accumulated a great deal of expertise on working effectively with bureaucrats and scraping up funds to finance policy programs.
If the LDP shows its political maturity by offering to provide the DPJ with all its expertise for running the government, the public perceptions of the opposition party could change dramatically.
The LDP, however, is acting as if it had never been in power and criticizing the misguided policies it introduced in the past.
The DPJ, on the other hand, is acting is if it had long been ruling the country even though it has been in power for just two years and trying to defend all the policies in place. This is a really bizarre political situation.
I hope both the ruling and opposition parties consider seriously what the role politics, as the ultimate service provider, is expected to play in this nation at the moment and how they should behave in order to accomplish their missions.
They should pay attention to the frustration being felt by Japanese voters, who are trying to live with such petty and ugly politics while straining to keep their senses.
(This article was compiled from an interview by Kishiko Hisada.)
* * *
Noriko Hama is professor of international economics at Doshisha University. After serving as head of the London representative office of the Mitsubishi Research Institute, she assumed her current post at Doshisha University in 2002.

Thursday, April 7, 2011

07/04 POINT OF VIEW/ Takeshi Soga: Where is the leader to offer a powerful vision of reconstruction?

2011/04/07

Takeshi Soga (The Asahi Shimbun)

During the past few weeks, while Japan has experienced the horrendous triple disasters of earthquake, tsunami and nuclear crisis, I have been amazed at the encouraging and uplifting power of simple, heartfelt words.

Take the pledge of fair play made by Shinsuke Noyama, captain of Soshi Gakuen High School from Okayama Prefecture, at the March 23 opening ceremony for the 83rd National High School Baseball Invitational Tournament held at Koshien Stadium in Nishinomiya, Hyogo Prefecture.

"Ganbaro, Nippon!" (Let's hang in there together, Japan), Noyama said. "We pledge to play fair and with all our might, while grateful for the lives given to us."

Emperor Akihito, in his video message to the nation on March 16, said, "It is my heartfelt hope that the people will continue to work hand in hand, treating each other with compassion, in order to overcome these trying times."

These are words of pledge and prayer. Brief, plain and to the point, they are deeply touching.

Yet our political leaders have yet to offer a single convincing statement about the disaster that strikes an emotional chord in the hearts of the people.

Prime Minister Naoto Kan said recently, "Whether we Japanese can overcome this crisis, that's a question posed to each and every one of us, I believe."

That was no pledge, nor did it offer a prayer. Was this question aimed at the public, or a rhetorical attempt to raise an issue? I have no idea.

Indeed, politicians and bureaucrats involved in the relief and recovery efforts are struggling over what and how much they should say in public.

"If we were to publish all information under the assumption that the worst could happen, not only the prime minister's office, but also the public would become upset," said one bureaucrat working to contain the nuclear crisis and prevent economic damage due to wild, unfounded rumors.

"If, however, we withhold certain information, we would, of course, lose our credibility when it finally is revealed. This crisis has made very clear to us, for the first time ever, how difficult it is to disclose information in such a way as to not panic the public amid such extraordinary circumstances," the bureaucrat said.

A midranking member of the opposition Liberal Democratic Party who is involved in developing a national reconstruction plan, faces another sticky dilemma.

"On one hand, if we don't learn the lessons of past major disasters like the Great Hanshin Earthquake (in 1995), we could end up with an unworkable plan," the LDP lawmaker said.

"But on the other hand, if we rely too much on past experiences, we won't be able to speak effectively about our responses to this unprecedented disaster, and we won't be able to use our imaginations (to improve the current crisis response)."

Since this is an unforeseen challenge for the nation, there is no immediate answer to such questions.

The public communication dilemmas facing politicians and bureaucrats are clear evidence that the March 11 triple disasters have badly shaken the foundation of this nation's political culture.

All this reminds me of comments that Izuru Makihara, a Tohoku University professor of political science, said in a debate published in the vernacular Asahi Shimbun opinion page just before the political regime change in 2009.

The Democratic Party of Japan, which was just about to usurp the LDP, should focus on how to "create a vision that appeals to voters" and "fit its policy agenda to that vision," Makihara said.

Individual policy initiatives and financing plans are only "parts of the political road map," he argued.

Makihara's observation is even more relevant today. Election manifestoes have lost their power to persuade. Making simple lists of numerical targets is passe.

Instead, political parties and politicians need to start shaping a new vision for this nation's future in their postquake rebuilding plans for eastern Japan, a powerful and persuasive goal for the 21st century.

Of course, a picture is worth a thousand words. The harrowing videos and photos of what happened in the quake and tsunami areas were far more effective than any words in making us grasp the horrifying scale of the devastation.

The only way to enable the people to envision a post-reconstruction future for this nation is to craft an imaginative and powerful plan for rebirth.

The nation is waiting to hear the voice of a great orator describing that future.

* * *

Takeshi Soga is a senior staff writer of The Asahi Shimbun.